kitio.aiMagicPost vs Comment Generator
A side-by-side look at pricing plans, free tiers, features, pros and cons, updated for 2026. Comment Generator has the lower starting price: about $10 a month, against $49 for MagicPost.
Chrome extension that drafts social comments in your own voice
Free trial · $9.99/moAt a glance
Best for
Pricing model
Starting price
Free plan
Made by
Based in
Rating
Key features
- AI post generator
- Carousel and visual creation
- LinkedIn scheduling
- Lead detection from engagement
- Client approval workflow
- API and MCP access
- Caption-aware comment drafts
- Objective and tone picker
- Custom voice instructions
- Multi-language replies
- No account access needed
| Feature | MagicPost | Comment Generator |
|---|---|---|
| Best for | LinkedIn content, scheduling and lead tool for creators and agencies | Chrome extension that drafts social comments in your own voice |
| Category | Marketing | Marketing |
| Pricing model | Free trial | Free trial |
| Starting price | $49/mo | $9.99/mo |
| Free plan | No, trial available | No, 7-day trial |
| Made by | MagicPost | Comment Generator |
| Based in | – | – |
| Rating | No ratings yet | No ratings yet |
| Key features |
|
|
Pricing compared
Comment Generator has the lower starting price: about $10 a month, against $49 for MagicPost.
Free plan
Cheapest paid plan
Top plan
Free trial
4 plans
Growth
$49/mo
- Analytics and performance tracking
- Lead detection from engagement
Agency
$59/mo
- Per user
- Minimum 5 client seats
- Client post approval
- White-label reports
Team
$59/mo
- Per user
- Minimum 5 seats
- Team dashboards
- Brand guidelines
Creator
$69/mo
- Unlimited post generation
- AI photos and carousels
- Comment scheduling
- API and MCP access
2 plans
Pro
$9.99/mo
- Per platform
- Up to 1,500 comments per month
- Cancel any time
Unlimited
$29.99/mo
- Per platform
- Unlimited comments
- Priority email and phone support
Prices in USD, checked Oct 29, 2026 or later. Plans change often, so confirm on each tool's site before you buy.
Pros and cons
MagicPost
- Writes in each person's own voice
- Uses LinkedIn's official API
- Built-in client approval for agencies
- Only covers LinkedIn
- Unlimited generation needs the Creator plan
- Agency and Team plans start at five seats
Comment Generator
- You review every comment
- Doesn't need your account login
- Replies in the post's language
- Priced per platform
- Chrome only
- Trial capped at 30 comments
Which one should you choose?
Choose MagicPost if you want:
- Writes in each person's own voice
- Uses LinkedIn's official API
- Built-in client approval for agencies
Watch out: only covers linkedin.
Choose Comment Generator if you want:
- You review every comment
- Doesn't need your account login
- Replies in the post's language
Watch out: priced per platform.
MagicPost vs Comment Generator FAQ
What is the difference between MagicPost and Comment Generator?
MagicPost: LinkedIn content, scheduling and lead tool for creators and agencies. Comment Generator: Chrome extension that drafts social comments in your own voice. Both are marketing tools.
Is MagicPost or Comment Generator cheaper?
Comment Generator has the lower starting price: about $10 a month, against $49 for MagicPost.
Do MagicPost and Comment Generator have free plans?
MagicPost: No, trial available. Comment Generator: No, 7-day trial.
Who makes MagicPost?
MagicPost is made by MagicPost.
Who makes Comment Generator?
Comment Generator is made by Comment Generator.
Which should I choose, MagicPost or Comment Generator?
Choose MagicPost if you value writes in each person's own voice and uses linkedin's official api. Choose Comment Generator if you value you review every comment and doesn't need your account login.